ASC New York midfielder Stalyn Acosta is off to a great start in Puerto Rico 

 By Peter Schwartz

When American Soccer Club-New York was founded, a goal for the franchise, aside from winning NPSL championships, was to be a club of opportunity and to be a pathway for area players to get to higher levels of soccer. An example of that is 19-year-old midfielder Stalyn Acostawho enjoyed a terrific 2025 season with the Fighting Tomcats and is now excelling in Puerto Rico.

The Brentwood native, a left back and center defensive midfielder, recently signed with Ponce FC in Liga Pro and is off to a terrific start with the club. Acosta scored a goal in his debut match picking up man of the match honors and then followed that up with two assists in his second match.

 “We’re incredibly proud of Stalyn,” said ASC New York Managing Partner and General Manager Jim Kilmeade. “His signing with Ponce FC and strong start in LigaPro reflects his powerful Long Island work ethic and commitment he showed every day at American Soccer Club-New York.This is a well-earned opportunity and we’re excited to see him continue to thrive in Puerto Rico.”

Acosta is a product of Brentwood SC from the Long Island Junior Soccer League and was a star for Brentwood High School joining the varsity team as a sophomore. Acosta was dealing with pain as he tried out for the club but wasn’t about to disclose it.

“I didn’t tell anybody I was going through this pain,” Acosta told CBS New York in July 2025. “I didn’t want to miss the tryout.

The 5-9 165-pound Acosta made the team but his sophomore season was cut short when he was diagnosed with Ewing sarcoma, a cancerous tumor that develops in the bone. Acosta would have a rib on his left side removed.

“It was like putting a rib on a grill and just burning it,” said Acosta.

Showing grit and determination, Acosta would return to the pitch nine months later when the cancer went into remission.

“Coming back my junior year was a hustle because I lost my hair…I lost everything,” said Acosta. “My conditioning wasn’t great.”

Things would eventually get better and then came a spectacular senior season.

That’s when he captained Brentwood to a perfect 22-0 record and the Class AAA state title and was a United Soccer Coaches All-America selection in 2023.  Acosta played his freshman year of college soccer at SUNY Cortland in 2024 playing in 18 games with six points on one goal and four assists. He was named to the State University of New York (SUNYAC) all-tournament team after he scored the opening goal of a 3-1 win over Buffalo State in the conference final.

“Stalyn is a warrior of a competitor,” said ASC New York Head Coach John Fitzgerald. “He’s gone through a lot for a young man and his mental toughness helps him persevere. His commitment to getting physically strong and to improving his game are starting to pay off. We’re very happy for him and proud of him and we support his journey as he goes forward. Though he’s playing for Ponce FC at the moment, he knows he’s still part of ASC New York and has a place with us.”

Stalyn Acosta is a source of inspiration for everyone and will always be an important part of the Fighting Tomcats family. The American Soccer Club-New York organization wishes him continued success in Puerto Rico and throughout his soccer journey.

About American Soccer Club-New York

Founded in 2024, the American Soccer Club-New York (ASC NY), known as the “Fighting Tomcats,” are a Long Island-Metro NY team, competing in the National Premier Soccer League. The club’s identity pays tribute to the region’s aviation heritage through the iconic Grumman F-14 Tomcat. ASC NY is committed to developing local talent and signed 16-year-old Dylan Lopez in its inaugural 2025 season. The Club’s focus is on engaging the community and elevating Long Island as the epicenter for American soccer development. The organization played its home matches at Hofstra University’s Captains Field in 2025 and has already made its mark with early competitive success, US Open Cup qualification and charitable partnerships, and a strong focus on youth development and regional pride.

For more information about American soccer Club- New York, please Contact ASCNY.